Commentary by George Lemako Prime Minister James Marape’s recent call for all senior public service appointments to be made on merit may appear as a bold reform agenda, but in reality, it serves more as a smoke screen than a serious commitment to change. His statements, made during the handover ceremony of the Health Secretary position, come at a time when public trust in government appointments is at an all-time low—undermined by years of politically motivated postings and nepotism.
Marape’s emphasis on qualifications, experience, and capability as criteria for appointments sounds noble. He even suggested the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) to assist the Department of Personnel Management (DPM) and the Public Services Commission (PSC) in ensuring fair selection. However, the Prime Minister's message seems less like a genuine reform and more like a public relations move designed to deflect attention from the systemic failures his administration has failed to correct.
0 Comments
Commentary by Wilfred Tuckerpin
I propose establishment of Tribal Mediation Commission, the best alternative function in addressing lasting peace in Papua New Guinea's total breakdown on Law & Order. PNG is vast in culture and tradition, in fact, very complex compared to any other society or country on this planet. The imported governance and Legal system cannot address the escalating Law & order crisis PNG is facing. I am talking about the seemingly never-ending tribal conflicts, violence, mass murder, genocide, rape, sorcery related killings, abuse of women & girls, prostitution, payback killings, etc... that are unstoppable! The state of absence of rule of law, weak government, lack of advocacy & mediation for peace settlement and enforcement of law in punishing perpetrators and warlords are recipes for revolution. Moreover, proliferation of illegal firearms, looting and burning down of private businesses/properties and seemingly no security as caused foreign businesses to consider winding down. Huge amount of investment by successive governments in addressing law & order has palled insignificant. Political instability, weak governance, weak disciplinary forces and scandals and corruption at the Government and Bureaucracy Level are contributing factors in insinuating citizens to take law into their hands. Commentary by George Lemako ![]() The recent disclosure by Hon. Bryan Kramer, Member of Parliament for Madang, regarding a substantial pay increase for Papua New Guinea’s Members of Parliament (MPs) under Prime Minister James Marape’s leadership has sparked widespread outrage among the nation’s taxpayers. This decision, which Kramer describes as both “heartbreaking” and a “complete injustice,” highlights a troubling disconnect between the government’s priorities and the economic realities faced by ordinary citizens. Below is a detailed commentary on this issue, unpacking the implications of Kramer’s revelations and the broader systemic issues they expose. The Pay Rise: A Financial Burden on Taxpayers In 2022, Prime Minister James Marape approved a retroactive pay increase for MPs, covering adjustments dating back to 2017. According to Kramer, this decision was made against his explicit advice, as he cautioned that such a move would be ill-received by a population grappling with financial hardship. The pay rise included significant back payments, ranging from K300,000 to K600,000 per MP, alongside increases in fortnightly net wages. Ordinary MPs saw their salaries rise from K12,000 to K16,000 per fortnight, while ministers’ wages increased from K21,000 to K28,000. These figures do not account for MPs’ access to millions of kina in public funds, which further amplifies the disparity between elected officials and the public they serve. Fletcher Morobe’s exit from Papua New Guinea is a deeply saddening but unsurprising development. It is a reflection of the tragic direction this nation is heading in—one overwhelmed by rampant corruption, a weakened Kina, and a flourishing culture of crony capitalism. In such an environment, it has become nearly impossible for honest, credible companies that helped build this nation to continue operating. They simply cannot compete under the current political and economic regime where integrity is seen as a disadvantage and backdoor dealings are the currency of success.
East Sepik Governor Allan Bird has issued a stark commentary on the state of governance in Papua New Guinea (PNG), emphasizing the urgent need for systemic change. According to Bird, the country’s centralized government system, where everything emanates from Waigani, has become a recipe for failure. The centralization means that when the center falters, the entire nation suffers. Key responsibilities like power, policing, fuel, water, jobs, and economic policy all rest with the national government, yet these areas are witnessing widespread dysfunction. Bird argues that addressing this structural flaw could resolve up to 80% of the nation's problems.
The frustration among the people is palpable, as they face mounting pressures in their daily lives. From rising living costs to inadequate services, the public is growing increasingly disillusioned with political leadership. This dissatisfaction stems not only from poor governance but also from the perceived indifference of politicians toward their struggles. People are weary and yearning for a leadership reset—a chance to breathe again after enduring six years of the current administration. For many, the call for change is not about who replaces Prime Minister Marape but rather ensuring that whoever takes charge provides hope and a fresh start. Opinion : By George Lemako,
Corruption in Papua New Guinea has become a deeply entrenched issue, with many allegations pointing directly at the government and Members of Parliament. Instead of addressing these concerns transparently, the government appears to be suppressing voices that expose corruption. The latest move to ban social media, particularly Facebook, raises serious questions about the government's intentions and its commitment to accountability. Social media platforms have played a crucial role in uncovering corruption in Papua New Guinea. Facebook, in particular, has been instrumental in providing a space for whistleblowers, journalists, and concerned citizens to share information and expose misconduct. However, the government is now moving to ban these platforms, a decision that seems to be aimed at silencing criticism rather than protecting the public. In the current term of Parliament, Hon. James Nomane, MP, has emerged as a formidable figure, striking the right chords at critical moments. His outspoken approach has sent a strong message, serving as a wake-up call to Prime Minister James Marape, Treasurer Ian Ling-Stuckey, and Members of Parliament across both sides of the political spectrum, including the National Executive Council (NEC). His fearless stance on pressing national issues has made him the talk of the nation at a time when Papua New Guinea is grappling with widespread poverty, escalating lawlessness, and economic instability.
Commentary by George Lemako The question of whether Papua New Guinea (PNG) can continue to elect individuals with low literacy levels and perceived low intelligence into Parliament is a pressing one that demands serious reflection. The Parliament serves as the epicenter of national governance, where the brightest minds are expected to deliberate on critical issues affecting the country at local, national, and international levels. When members of Parliament lack the necessary intellectual capacity or educational foundation to contribute meaningfully, it undermines the very purpose of this institution and raises concerns about the nation's future.
Parliament is not merely a legislative body; it is a reflection of the nation’s values, education system, and societal priorities. It provides a glimpse into how well-educated and competent the population is, particularly those entrusted with leadership roles. Allowing individuals who are uneducated, illiterate, or intellectually unprepared to occupy seats in Parliament tarnishes the image of the nation. Such representation does not inspire confidence domestically or internationally but instead fosters perceptions of incompetence and mediocrity. Commentary by George Lemako The continuous attack on Papua New Guinea's Constitution through frequent amendments to serve the government's interests is alarming. Such actions set a dangerous precedent, undermining the very principles of democracy and good governance. When leaders manipulate the Constitution to maintain power, they erode public trust and weaken the foundations of the nation’s legal framework.
One of the most concerning aspects of these amendments is their long-term impact. Today, one government makes changes to suit its political survival; tomorrow, another will do the same. Over time, this cycle renders the Constitution meaningless, as it ceases to function as a safeguard for citizens’ rights and instead becomes a tool for political convenience. This approach threatens the balance of power and weakens democratic institutions. Once again, Prime Minister James Marape has placed the blame for Papua New Guinea’s law and order crisis squarely on past governments. Rejecting calls for his resignation, he insists that the chaos unfolding in the country is the result of years of neglect by successive administrations. But how long can he continue this narrative before accepting that, after nearly five years in power, the responsibility to fix these problems now rests on his shoulders?
Marape argues that his government inherited a police force in total decline, with inadequate resources and untrained personnel—even at the highest levels. While this may be true, it is also undeniable that under his leadership, crime has worsened, police capacity remains insufficient, and public confidence in law enforcement is at an all-time low. His list of supposed reforms—police recruitment, training, and agency coordination—sounds promising on paper, yet the country continues to experience lawlessness at an alarming rate. |
PNG Politics WatchPNG Political analysis, Gossips ,Commentaries, news and ViewsPapua New Guinea Politics, news and commentaries . Send us your PNG Political view to us for publication on this page . Contact us |